deviant art

Deviant Login Shop  Join deviantART for FREE Take the Tour
[x]
more ▶

Featured in Groups:

Details

January 11, 2009
Link
Thumb

Statistics

Comments: 24
Favourites: 0
Views: 62 (0 today)
[x]

Plagium?!

Journal Entry: Sun Jan 11, 2009, 6:25 AM


Today !sunabora showed me this deviation:



This deviation belongs to ~stefanSia and it is very similar to my first deviation here on DA




I know that meeting similar photos is unevitable in a big community, but here almost the title is the same. I don't know whether she saw this deviation of mine or not, but I find it very strange.

I found my comment on her wall that I made a month before she submitted her stuff.

[link]

So I am almost sure she stole my idea.

I think when someone calls himself artist then should be creative enough to create new ideas.

What do you think about it?

  • Mood: Irritated
Add a Comment:
 
:icondiemathos:
Csinálj jobbat. És akkor nincs plágium. Ennyi.

Amúgy sajnos igaza van az illetőnek. Gondolkodj, járj utána, és neki írd meg mielőtt mindenkinek szétkürtölöd a dolgokat, amiben ráadásul még nem is vagy biztos... Most sztem Te lettél kicsit beégetve.....
Reply
:iconstefansia:
this is the note:

hello dear.
i'm really hurted by your comment... because i shot that photo so long ago.. and it was online on flickr more time ago than your's.
i'm not a fake, i think that's clear looking at my gallery, and i'm really sorry that one of mine can make you sue you're the first who had that idea!!!
my cofee cup is not like your's.. in italy is reaaly different.. and my photo is about tea cup.. i've hidden your comment because i had no time to reply and it was bad for me and my personal works!!!
so.. my mother is from budapest.. i've watched you for that, i've seen that you're hungarian too...
i think that it was a misunderstanding between us.. now do what you think it's right but... remember my words.. i'm not a thief.. never! fake?? i don't know what you mean.. i'm honest.. and pround to be!
you've to think longer before telling people they are bad..
anyway.. if you want to speak about.. add me on msn.. my account is in my info ;)
bye
Reply
:iconstefansia:
lol!!!
i've send you a note!
i'm not a thief.. if i was.. all my ideas were the same...
anyway...
mine is a cup of tea.. and your's not.. maybe coffee.. second.. i posted it so long ago on flickr..
maybe in every photo you can see something that you have already done.. mah!
i'm really shocked..
if it's makes you happy.. i'll edit my photo.. linkin' yours!! ;)
Reply
:iconlifeiscreative:
~lifeiscreative Jan 14, 2009   Photographer
Could you give me a flickR link?
Reply
:icontmphotographia:
~TMPhotographia Jan 11, 2009  Student Photographer
I think it is VERY obvious the concept and even the title were taken. I also agree that you really need to have your own ideas to be an "artist". It really is a shame that she stole your idea and also suggest keeping an eye on her, and/or even reporting this instance to an admin. I really just feel the need to say the very obvious fact that your shot is by far the better of the two ;p
Reply
:iconlifeiscreative:
~lifeiscreative Jan 12, 2009   Photographer
Thanks for your support :hug:
Reply
:icontmphotographia:
~TMPhotographia Jan 12, 2009  Student Photographer
Just doing my job my job ;p
Reply
:iconyyersya:
Only English comment on here, lol.
That really sucks. I'd watch her, and if she does it again, report her, or something. No one should be able to get away with that.
Reply
:iconlifeiscreative:
~lifeiscreative Jan 11, 2009   Photographer
:hug:
Reply
:iconideoda:
Rengeteg ehhez hasonló ké.pet láttam már itt.. nincs új a nap alatt. Néha másoktól merítünk ötletet, amivel nincs is baj, míg plagizálásba át nem lé.pünk. Mindannyiunknak van mit gyakorolni, és hosszú az út..
nem érdemes fennakadni ilyeneken (a tied máskülönben jobb!)

:pointr: [link]
Reply
Add a Comment: